Kee Safety Kee Safety is a leading global supplier of fall protection and safe access products, services and training.
View all
Get a Quote Today

Partner Portal

+1 (800) 851-5181

Partner Portal +1 (800) 851-5181
Kee Safety Kee Safety is a leading global supplier of fall protection and safe access products, services and training.
Get a Quote Today
Kee Safety Kee Safety is a leading global supplier of fall protection and safe access products, services and training.
Get a Quote Today
KS KGU 317

Permanent vs. Temporary Guardrail: Choosing the Right Fall Protection for Your Building

15 Nov 2023
Share LinkedIn Facebook Twitter

Are you grappling with the decision of installing the right guardrail system for your building? It's a common dilemma in the world of workplace safety: choosing between permanent and temporary guardrails. Both options can be compliant with OSHA regulations and offer fall protection, but they serve different needs and environments. Understanding the key differences between these two can help you make an informed decision for your building.

KS KGU 1779

Understanding the Basics

OSHA mandates fall protection for employees working or walking at heights of 4 feet or higher in general industry, and above 6 feet in construction. This protection must include a guardrail system that is approximately 42 inches in height. Whether you opt for a permanent or temporary guardrail system, adherence to OSHA standards is non-negotiable.

Before diving into the specifics, it's essential to understand what we mean by permanent and temporary guardrail systems.

  • Permanent Guardrails are fixed installations, designed to provide long-term safety solutions. They are typically used in areas where regular access is required, and fall risks are constant.
  • Temporary Guardrails, on the other hand, are portable and adjustable. They can be used for short-term projects or situations where flexibility is needed.
KS KGU 1875

Permanent Guardrails: Pros and Cons

Pros:

  1. Durability: Built to last, these guardrails are made with robust materials to withstand harsh weather and wear and tear.
  2. Continuous Protection: They offer uninterrupted safety for areas like rooftops, walkways, and industrial platforms.
  3. Low Maintenance: Once installed, they require minimal upkeep, saving time and resources in the long run.

Cons:

  1. Initial Cost: The upfront investment can be higher due to the quality of materials and installation requirements.
  2. Less Flexibility: Being a fixed solution, they are may not suitable for temporary work sites.
Adobestock 84027122 Web

Temporary Guardrails: Pros and Cons

Pros:

  1. Flexibility: Easily installed and moved, these systems are perfect for short-term projects or changing work environments.
  2. Cost-Effective: They offer a more affordable solution for temporary needs without compromising safety.
  3. Ease of Installation: Quick to set up and dismantle, saving valuable time on the job.

Cons:

  1. Ongoing Adjustments: They may require more frequent checks and adjustments to ensure safety.
  2. Limited Durability: While still safe and reliable, they may not withstand the same level of wear and tear as permanent solutions.
KS KG IMG 4312 (1)

Choosing the Right System for Your Needs

The decision between a permanent and temporary guardrail system depends on several factors:

  • Duration and Frequency of Use: For long-term, frequent usage, permanent guardrails are more suitable. Temporary guardrails are ideal for short-term projects.
  • Environment: Consider the environmental conditions. Permanent solutions are better for harsh conditions.
  • Budget: Assess your budget constraints. Temporary guardrails can be more cost-effective for short-term needs.

Conclusion: Both permanent and temporary guardrail systems play a crucial role in fall protection. At Kee Safety, we are committed to providing high-quality, reliable solutions for all your safety needs. Whether you require a permanent installation for ongoing protection or a temporary solution for a specific project, we have the expertise and products to keep your workplace safe.

roof edge protection

Making the Right Choice

At Kee Safety, we are committed to providing high-quality, reliable solutions for all your safety needs. Whether you require a permanent installation for ongoing protection or a temporary solution for a specific project, we have the expertise and products to keep your workplace safe. Consulting with a fall protection expert is crucial to tailor a solution that fits your unique facility, workforce, and processes. A competent professional can guide you through the options, ensuring OSHA compliance and optimal safety.

Contact us today to set up a consultation with a fall protection specialist in your area from Kee Safety.

About the Author

Dan Huntington

Daniel Huntington is an experienced sales and technical product trainer with a demonstrated history of working in the Fall Protection Industry. As a Fall Protection Industry Expert, he is formally trained in OSHA fall protection standards and risk assessment. He is a respected compliance educator and trainer in rooftop safety, presenting at the 2019 ASSP Expo for the International Society of Fall Protection (ISFP) where he facilitated a course on improving safety for people working at height.

Website: https://www.keesafety.com/

Email: info@keesafety.com

Author image of Dan Huntington
金属屋面护栏

Safety is Kee, let us help protect your team

Please fill in your details below and we’ll be in touch shortly.

Talk to our specialists about your needs

Contact

Safety Newsletter

Please enter your information to stay informed about safety articles, products and services.